How Conversion Rates Have Artificially Doubled in the Last Four Years

In the evolving digital marketing landscape, CEOs, CMOs, marketing and product executives rely heavily on key performance metrics to guide their strategies and decisions. Among these metrics, conversion rates - such as those seen in onboarding funnels, sign-up funnels or order ratios - stand out as pivotal measures of success. These metrics are not only critical for evaluating current performance and defining strategic areas to tackle but are also essential for deriving optimizations that can significantly impact future success.

However, a closer examination of the trends over the last four years reveals a startling reality: the apparent improvement in conversion rates may not be as genuine as it seems. Influences such as evolving user engagement with consent banners and increased browser privacy measures have artificially inflated these metrics, potentially affecting conversion rates by 100% or more. This significant distortion challenges the authenticity of perceived performance improvements. If the conversion rate on a four-year timeline appears unchanged, the situation is likely even more dire: in reality, the actual conversion rate might be less than half of the reported figure, illustrating a profound discrepancy between perceived and actual performance.

‍

Unpacking the Factors Behind the Illusion

1) Consent Banner Interactions

The dynamics of user engagement with consent banners significantly distort conversion rate metrics. The implementation and evolution of consent banners from opt-out to opt-in models, driven by stricter regulatory guidelines since 2019, have fundamentally altered user consent capture and analysis, leading to a pronounced impact on conversion rates. Over this period, the landscape has been shaped not only by the shift from opt-out to opt-in models but also by clear directives from data protection authorities and the phased responses of platform operators. Initially, there was an absence of reject buttons (2019), gradually moving to reject options on the second layer of consent interfaces (2020 - 2021), and eventually to the inclusion of reject buttons prominently on the first layer (2022 - 2024). This evolution reflects a trajectory towards greater transparency and user control over personal data processing, affecting measured user behavior across different segments, marketing channels, and devices.

• Existing vs. New Users: Existing customers, already familiar with a brand, are more likely to interact positively with consent banners, granting the permissions needed for tracking with higher conversion rates compared to new users. This results in a more comprehensive capture of their activities and, consequently, artificially higher overall conversion metrics. In contrast, new users, lacking prior brand engagement and possibly more privacy-conscious, tend to withhold consent by ignoring the banner, bouncing off the site, or explicitly clicking the 'decline' button. This behavior leads to a significant portion of user interactions going untracked.
  
• Variability Across Marketing Channels: The impact of consent banner interactions also varies significantly across different marketing channels. For example, channels like display advertising, known for high volumes of impressions but lower conversion rates, often suffer from accidental clicks. Many of these accidental visitors may not interact with the consent banner, leading to their exclusion from web analytics. This lack of interaction falsely inflates conversion rates by omitting a large volume of non-engaged traffic from the analysis. The differential in consent rates between engaged and disengaged users, compounded by discrepancies across marketing channels, amplifies the illusion of improved conversion rates, as the data increasingly reflects the behavior of a segment predisposed to engagement.

2) Browser Restrictions

The landscape of digital tracking has been further complicated by browser-imposed restrictions on third-party cookies and tracking technologies. Major web browsers like Apple's Safari have implemented in 2023 measures that block tools such as the Google Tag Manager and Google Analytics in private browsing modes. This severely limits the ability of marketers to track user behavior across sessions and devices, contributing to the illusion of improved conversion rates. Currently, approximately 20% of Apple users utilize the private browsing mode, where such restrictions are active, meaning a significant portion of user engagement goes untracked.

As privacy developments progress, the question arises: How will the data quality be affected if Apple decides to extend these restrictions to the non-private browsing mode? The potential for Apple to roll out such changes could significantly impact data science and BI teams, making it challenging to capture data from devices (i.e., iPhone). The implications for data-driven decision-making, are profound, as the absence of data from a significant segment of users would hinder the accuracy and reliability of analytics, affecting the development of insights and strategies.

Our Solution: A Custom Measurement Approach

In response to these challenges, our team has developed a cutting-edge solution designed to restore accuracy to conversion rate metrics without compromising user privacy. Our approach leverages server-side measurement technology that operates independently of third-party cookies, first-party cookies, external trackings and browser restrictions.

Key Features of Our Solution

• Privacy Compliance: Our solution adheres to the strictest privacy standards, ensuring compliance with GDPR and other data protection regulations.
• Accurate Data Collection: Server-side measurement offers a more reliable view of user behavior, unaffected by browser restrictions and consent-management.
• Customizable Metrics: Businesses can define and measure conversion metrics based on their unique objectives, enabling deeper insights.
• Data Ownership: Data stored on company servers enhances stability and allows for more flexible and avancded analysis and tests.
• Segmented Conversion Rates: Conversion Rates by Device, Campaign, Channel, Browser, New and Existing Customer
• Reporting: Visualization is possible everywhere: in existing BI systems, your own dashboards, or interfaces developed by us, providing versatile options for accessing and interpreting your data with ease.

Implementing Our Solution

We provide end-to-end support for integrating our server-side measurement technology into existing digital architectures, ensuring seamless integration with no disruption to ongoing operations.

Conclusion

The illusion of improved conversion rates necessitates a reevaluation of traditional measurement methods. By adopting our innovative server-side measurement solution, businesses can navigate the complexities of the digital landscape with confidence, achieving a more accurate understanding of their marketing performance while upholding the highest standards of user privacy.

In light of these challenges and opportunities, we warmly invite interested parties to engage in a non-binding conversation about our solutions. If you're looking to gain a clearer understanding of how these technologies can benefit your business and rectify the inaccuracies in conversion rate measurement, please feel free to reach out to us. We're here to help you make informed decisions that align with your strategic goals and navigate the evolving digital marketing environment with precision and insight.